LEG 3 – London Engineering Group Publishes Revised LEG Exclusion Clauses
November 2026In our previous article, we commented on the London Engineering Group’s (“LEG”) announcement that revised versions of the LEG defect exclusion clauses were expected to be published, following concerns raised as to their judicial treatment, arising from some recent US decisions. In particular, in South Capitol Bridgebuilders v Lexington Insurance Company (“SCB v Lexington”)[1], where questions were raised regarding the scope and operation of the existing clauses, particularly in relation to the distinction between a “defect” and “damage” and, in the case of LEG 3, the meaning of “improvement”.
The revisions also come against a backdrop of reported market concern following the US decisions, with some insurers moving away from the use of LEG 3 wording on certain risks. The publication of the revised clauses may therefore be viewed as an attempt not only to clarify the wording itself, but also to reinforce confidence in the continued international use of the LEG suite.
LEG has indicated that the purpose of the revisions is not to alter the underlying allocation of risk between insurers and policyholders, but rather to clarify the operation of the clauses and ensure that they remain fit for purpose in the modern construction insurance market.
In November 2026, LEG has now published its revised suite of defect exclusion clauses, comprising LEG 1/26, LEG 2/26 and LEG 3/26, together with accompanying commentary explaining the drafting intent and intended operation of the clauses. While the guidance makes clear that it is not intended to be legally binding and that parties remain free to amend or disregard the clauses as they see fit, it nevertheless provides valuable insight into the objectives underpinning the revisions.
Defining Damage and Defect
As we suggested would be beneficial in our previous article, a significant change across all three clauses is the introduction of express definitions of both “Damage” and “Defect”.
“Damage” is defined as physical loss, physical destruction or an adverse physical change to property existent at the time such loss, destruction or change occurs. The accompanying commentary emphasises that the existence of a defect alone does not constitute damage. Property may be defective but unless there has been physical loss, destruction or an adverse physical change, no damage has occurred. The revised clauses also expressly state that existent refers to actual, tangible property, not property that will exist at a future stage or a construction project.
A “Defect” is now defined as a characteristic of the material, workmanship, design, plan or specification of property which renders that property less fit for purpose than intended when it was made, built, installed or constructed.
The definitions appear intended to address one of the key issues highlighted by the recent US decisions, and general interpretation of the clauses, namely the distinction between “defect” and “damage”. The inclusion of express definitions should provide greater clarity for contracting parties, reducing the need to rely on judicial interpretation of those terms.
LEG 1/26
The revised LEG 1/26 remains the most restrictive of the three exclusions. The clause now expressly excludes “Damage caused by a Defect in the Insured Property”. The accompanying guidance describes this as an absolute exclusion. LEG 1/26 also excludes intentional damage caused. This is likely directed towards situations where parts of a project must be deliberately deconstructed to gain access to defective works.
The commentary also makes clear that the existence of a Defect does not, of itself, constitute Damage, nor does the mere introduction of defective property into other insured property. This reinforces the distinction between a defective condition and insured physical damage. The LEG 1 exclusion therefore remains broadly consistent with its previous incarnation, albeit with clearer drafting and the benefit of the newly introduced definitions and commentary.
LEG 2/26
LEG 2 has historically been viewed as excluding the costs that would have been incurred to remedy the defect itself whilst preserving cover for resulting damage. The revised LEG 2/26 seeks to clarify the approach. The exclusion operates by deducting from the loss “an amount equal to the costs that would have been incurred to replace or rectify Insured Property having the Defect, as if such Defect had been discovered immediately prior to the Damage”.
The commentary provides useful guidance on how it is intended to operate. Insurers are required to undertake a hypothetical assessment and ask what it would have cost to rectify the Defect had it been discovered immediately before Damage occurred, that amount is then excluded from the claim, with the balance potentially being recoverable. To calculate this amount, the occurrence of the Damage is effectively put on hold whilst a rectification scheme is identified and costed. The commentary also confirms that the existence of a Defect alone does not amount to Damage and that the incorporation of defective property into other insured property does not, without more, trigger an insured loss.
The revised wording appears to be designed to provide a clearer framework for adjusting losses involving defective property insured whilst maintaining the established distinction between rectification costs and resultant damage.
LEG 3/26
The revised LEG 3/26 is likely to attract the greatest attention given the criticism directed at the previous wording in the recent US proceedings. One of the main criticisms of the LEG 3/06 wording was uncertainty surrounding the exclusion of costs incurred to “improve” the original material, workmanship, design, plan or specification. In Archer Western-De Moya Joint Venture v Ace American Insurance Company (“Archer v ACE”)[2], the courts in Florida questioned what, in practical terms, constituted “improvement” and concluded that the concept was ambiguous.
The revised LEG 3/26 retains the principle that costs of improvement are excluded but seeks to add clarity to it by excluding “the additional cost incurred to improve the material, workmanship, design, plan or specification that was utilised to make, install, build or construct the Insured Property that has the Defect”.
The drafting appears intended to make clear that the exclusion is confined to the incremental cost of improvement beyond that originally provided, rather than excluding the wider cost of repairing damage.
A further noteworthy addition concerns what the commentary refers to as “Access Damage”. The clause excludes intentional damage caused to enable the replacement or rectification of defective property, unless that damage is necessary to repair insured damage.
The guidance contemplates circumstances where access works coincide with the repair of covered damage. In such cases, the costs associated with the access damage may remain recoverable, subject to the operation of the improvement exclusion and wider policy terms. This aspect of the revised clauses may assist in addressing disputes that can arise where substantial costs associated with access to investigate, repair or replace etc. defective or damaged property insured.
Do the revisions address the concerns raised by the US decisions?
The revisions appear to represent a direct response to the issues highlighted in the cases of both SCB v Lexington and Archer v ACE. LEG has sought to remove uncertainty whilst also confirming that defective property does not become damaged merely because it fails to meet a required standard or specification.
The definitions of “Damage” and “Defect” appear broadly consistent with the approach adopted by the English courts in Sky UK Ltd and Mace Ltd v Riverstone Managing Agency Ltd[3], where the Court of Appeal held that damage requires a physical change that impairs the value or usefulness of the property.
Commentary
The publication of LEG 1/26, LEG 2/26 and LEG 3/26 represents the most significant revision of the LEG defect exclusions in almost two decades. Although, as existing policies may continue to incorporate previous versions of the LEG clauses for some time, the publication of the revised wording is unlikely to eliminate disputes immediately.
The revised exclusions do provide clearer terms. However, it is likely that disputes will continue to arise as to what is defective or damaged, or indeed what the cost of improvement are, on a case-by-case basis.
Careful consideration should therefore continue to be given to the precise wording incorporated into each policy and the governing law applicable to its interpretation.
The revisions do not fundamentally alter the traditional allocation of risk embodied within the LEG suite. Rather, their principal objective appears to be clarification. The introduction of express definitions of “Damage” and “Defect”, together with more detailed drafting concerning rectification costs, improvements and access-related losses, reflects an effort to address the criticisms that emerged following the recent US authorities and to provide clarity to ambiguities.
The publication of accompanying commentary is also noteworthy. Whilst not legally binding, it provides insurers, brokers, policyholders and courts with a contemporaneous explanation of the drafting intent, which may assist in promoting a more consistent approach to interpretation across jurisdictions.
Whether the revised wording ultimately achieves that objective will depend on how it is adopted by the market and in due course, interpreted by the courts.
Get in Touch
Beale & Co regularly advise on construction all risks policies and the operation of defect exclusion clauses. If you would like to discuss any of the issues raised in this article, please contact Nathan Modell or Bethany Turner.
[1] (D.D.C. Sep 29, 2023), a case before the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.
[2] Docket No: CASE NO. 1:22-CV-21160-GOODMAN, a summary judgment application by ACE in the US District Court for the Southern District of Florida.
[3] [2024] EWCA Civ 1567.
Download PDF

